The Recurring Cast
Imagined crossover · Forensics and profilers

What if Maura Isles met Kay Scarpetta?

The medical examiners. Two meticulous, brilliant pathologists who speak for the dead.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Artwork: Maura Isles meets Kay Scarpetta

The pair

Maura IslesMedical examinerBy Tess Gerritsen · Rizzoli and Isles · first in The Apprentice
Kay ScarpettaChief medical examiner and forensic pathologistBy Patricia Cornwell · Kay Scarpetta · first in Postmortem
Chemistry7/10
Friction7/10
Would you read this crossover?

Where and when

Boston and Cambridge
The 2010s

The story

How they might meet
A body found on the Charles River falls between two jurisdictions, and both chief medical examiners claim the autopsy.
Why they would work
Two meticulous, brilliant pathologists who speak for the dead.
What each brings
Maura is precise, rational and calm. Kay is experienced, determined and has a lifetime of difficult cases behind her.
Where they would clash
Two queens of the morgue with very firm ideas about procedure.

Strengths compared

Maura Isles Kay Scarpetta

DeductionMuscleRule-bendingWitHeartResourcesMaura Isles: Deduction 9 out of 10Maura Isles: Muscle 2 out of 10Maura Isles: Rule-bending 3 out of 10Maura Isles: Wit 4 out of 10Maura Isles: Heart 6 out of 10Maura Isles: Resources 7 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Deduction 9 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Muscle 2 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Rule-bending 4 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Wit 3 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Heart 7 out of 10Kay Scarpetta: Resources 9 out of 10

Our own ratings out of 10, for fun.

On the page together

In print together 2002–2022Maura Isles · 2002–2022Kay Scarpetta · 1990–20251990200020102020

The years in which each character's books were published.

Read your way in

Start with each character's first appearance.

More crossovers like this

← Lincoln Rhyme and Temperance BrennanAll crossoversSara Linton and Temperance Brennan →

Share this crossover: Facebook · X · Reddit · Email